(CNN) — Overlook “Lord of the Flies.” If you want to see nature red in tooth and claw, lock a bunch of humans inside a pressurized tube for eight hours and see how swiftly they divide into factions.

With verify-in travelers on 1 side and carry-on devotees on the other, it is a darn fantastic point weapons are not permitted in the airplane cabin.

We asked CNN Travel readers to inform us exactly where they stand the on the excellent luggage debate, just after two CNN staffers laid out the pros and cons.

Your answers have been impassioned, thoughtful and informative. We had close to 500 responses, and they divided into 3 camps.

Verify-in enthusiasts have been the most significant group, at 37%, carry-on aficionados created up 33% of the feedback, and 30% of individuals mentioned, “it depends on the trip.”

See what readers had to say under. (Responses have been edited for brevity).

Verify oneself prior to you wreck oneself

Verify-in fans really like that they can glide hassle-no cost all through the airport and say that it requires a lot of the pressure out of traveling.

“I perform for an airline and travel often. I attempt to pack light but often verify in my bag, even if it is carry-on size, as I hate carrying luggage via safety and the airport.” (Alketa).

Weight expectations

When traveling for lengthy periods or to a cold climate, it is tough to squeeze all your goods into a carry-on. Also, lots of travelers have specific specifications — health-related gear, infant strollers, canes, you name it — and pared-down packing just is not an selection.

Then there is the basic reality that some of us are larger than other people. “I am a fairly major guy and these rinky-dinky carry-ons just do not reduce the mustard for me.” (English on Delivery, Japan.)

Unfair policy

Quite a few individuals have physical troubles which just avoid them from reaching up to place luggage in an overhead bin.

“Forcing the disabled, height-challenged and elderly to spend for a checked bag is discriminatory.” (Terry Schumann, Sylva, NC.)

“What to do when you are a disabled individual who should carry extras and/or replacement things in case anything essential is lost or broken? Two distinct airlines broke my rolling walker and I had to use a cane (tucked into checked luggage) till I discovered one more. Airlines extremely, extremely typically refuse to assist.” (Austin, Texas.)

Liberate our legs

A popular aggravation of these who’ve checked in their bags is then becoming asked to place their carry-on bag beneath the seat in front in order to make area for carry-on passengers’ suitcases in the overhead bin. “Not only is this uncomfortable, but I am potentially smashing something in there with my feet,” Says Nick from Suburban Chicago.

Free of charge the aisle

Our readers hate it when individuals block the aisle when loading or unpacking bags. “The overhead hassles (not to mention competitors) are annoying at greatest and life-threatening at worst,” says Jim Steele, pointing out that it can hinder an emergency evacuation.

Verify in and stay away from the line

“I can afford to just wait out the boarding zone calls. I bide my time till all the overhead crammers are on, and completed (safeguarding my head from these individuals attempting to catapult their carry ons above me).” (Lesley Peter, Yucatan, Mexico).

People today really like Southwest

Southwest Airlines is adored by some fliers for its check-in bag policies.

Southwest Airlines is adored by some fliers for its verify-in bag policies.

AFP/Getty Pictures/File

A lot of readers travel with checked luggage for no cost thanks to credit cards linked to airlines. There was also a large quantity of really like for Southwest Airlines.

“I genuinely want that fewer airlines ripped individuals off with baggage charges, and a lot more have been like Southwest with their two no cost checked bags. If you have ever flown on Southwest you know that there is lots of overhead bin space and boarding goes quicker even on a complete flight for the reason that individuals can verify a bag with out paying via the nose.” (Dave Sturtz, Gold Hill, Colorado.)

Traveling for enterprise

“In the previous, carry-on was the wise enterprise traveler move, but now Absolutely everyone has a carry on. Now you join the fight for overhead space, the hell that is the TSA verify, and the dreaded wait in a unorganized line when they have gate-verify.” (John Gibson, Omaha NE.)

Packing light and re-applying clothes is not an selection when you are “attempting to make an impression in a enterprise atmosphere. When your schedule is crammed, then you pack the exact same, leaving absolutely nothing for likelihood.” (Judith Ganes, Panama City, Panama.)

Gate verify-in: The case for and against

“Any time I fly, I pack a carry-on. As soon as I attain the gate, the employees inevitably asks for volunteers to verify their bags — for no cost (and I gratefully indulge).” (Jessalyn Goodman, Cincinnati, OH.)

“With low-expense airlines, there is often a likelihood your cautiously packed carry-on luggage gets thrown into verify-in at the counter.” (Dr. Gopinath, Hyderabad, India.)

“The airlines have forced the existing AWFUL predicament. Most individuals know they can gate-verify their carry-on for no cost, so now the gate region functions like the verify-in counter utilized to, and the jetway is now like baggage claim. It is crowded, slow, stupid, and just a terrible practical experience.” (Andrew, Madison, WI.)

Rhonda Howard from Chicago: “My vote is that everybody has to spend for their luggage… or no 1 does.” (Rhonda Howard, Chicago).

Checked luggage weight is essential

“Pilots need to have to figure luggage weight into the weight and balance of the aircraft. Verify your bags, give the pilots the information they need to have, maintain a baggage handler employed, save your back, board with ease and slow down.” (Gina from Maryland, retired flight attendant.)

Hold calm and carry on

Sometimes checking those bags is the only option.

At times checking these bags is the only selection.

Getty/ Alexander Hassenstein / Employees

Show me the funds

“I refuse to spend additional for anything that was as soon as no cost.” (Erika Orejola Orange, Ca.)

Save time

Carry-on aficionados really like that they can arrive at the airport in additional-squeaky time and skip out faster also. It can also make it simpler to make a tight connection.

“E-tickets plus no verify-in queues and no baggage claim let me shave at least an hour of airport practical experience every way. That is worth each bit of inconvenience I have in needing to cautiously fold my garments.” (Stephen, UK).


“When flights are canceled/delayed, and you stand in line to be rebooked, they will typically ask ‘Do you have checked baggage?’ If you are only holding a carry-on, they have a lot more flexibility in re-routing your flights.” (Quin Wetzel, Cincinnati, OH.)

Derek from Florida got stuck in a bag-drop line for a lot more than an hour and, possessing missed his flight, was place on standby. “I did not finish up creating it to my location, as all flights have been complete. At least my checked bag had a good stop by to St. Louis, when I stood waiting standby at the airport.”

Board early

Nevertheless, passengers mentioned they had to board early — either by obtaining in line, acquiring priority boarding, or possessing airline status — if they have been to be particular of obtaining their bags in the bin.

“The basic reality is that the larger your status on the airline the sooner you get on the plane. The low status/no status passengers will be checking their bags at the gate.” (Art, USA).

Take back handle

Though verify-in fans really like feeling liberated from their bags, carry-on devotees say they delight in feeling in handle of exactly where they and their luggage are going and when. Clever packers had lots of guidelines to provide, from ziplock bags to packing cubes to strong conditioner for hair.

“Put on your nicest outfit on the plane. In addition to saving a lot of space, you have a tendency to get treated improved.” (H. Green, Chicago, IL.)

Paring down

“With a checked bag I typically finish up with garments/footwear I under no circumstances touch, and understand when unpacking that I genuinely did not need to have them.” (Sandy Tello, Houston.)

“It is simpler to navigate as soon as you arrive at your location. As a 5’1 solo traveler it is not feasible for me to drag a suitcase practically as major as me about cobblestone streets, subways and buses.” (Heather Shank, Louisville, KY.)

Hold luggage beautiful

“Luggage is so fairly when you 1st obtain it. By the time it is created 1 trip in a cargo hold, it floats down the tiny conveyor belt in a baggage claim with dents, black marks, scrapes, and broken locks.” (Allison, Houston, TX.)

Valuable items

A lot of individuals — specially these with high priced camera gear or important medication — like to maintain anything close by.

“What ever indifference airlines have towards their passengers, multiply it for their luggage.” (Joshua Mellin, Chicago.)

“On the uncommon occasion I have checked a bag and been separated from it, it is good to know I will not die in some strange location with out clean underwear.” (Chip Brown).

As soon as bitten, twice shy

“Following you have had luggage not show up (in some instances under no circumstances obtaining it back) many instances you just make certain you will have it at your location by carrying it on.” (Gail).

The squeezed middle

About a third of individuals who responded mentioned that there have been a variety of variables affecting their choice to go verify-in or carry-on: price tag, duration of trip, time of year, no matter whether they have been packing gifts and so on.

And the major point everybody had in popular? A get in touch with for consideration for one’s fellow passengers.

Obey the guidelines

“I am enraged at the size of carry-ons individuals bring onto planes.” (Charlotte, Fairfax, VA).

“I had an practical experience in which a guy broke the luggage bin attempting to close the door on an oversized case. It expense more than an hour of delay to repair the bin.” (Mark A. Butterworth, Muscatine, IA).

Never hog the bins

“However, there are passengers who have seats close to the back of the plane who like to stow their carry-ons closer to the front so they do not have to deal with them in the narrow aisles. Typical courtesy would dictate that everybody location their carry-on in the compartment more than their seat.” (Jim from Germany.)

Charge for carry-ons?

“I feel airlines really should charge for carry-ons and make checked bags no cost, to streamline boarding and deplaning.” (Frank Perch, Philadelphia). Diane in

“I would vote for seat-assigned, strictly size restricted overhead compartments which expense funds to book.” (Ruech, Munich.)

“The challenge these days is being aware of what airline makes it possible for what. Gone are the days when practically each airline had the exact same guidelines.” (Ken McLeod, Ayrshire, Scotland.)

An option

“I send my baggage with Federal Express and so forth to my hotel and back in a sturdy aluminum case. That way you can take something.” (Fran Gerber).